Why bar totals must be read with their chart interval.
Verdict: a higher bar count does not prove a more complete history. Gold Snap records 7,901,463 bars because its chart interval is finer than the other examples.
Audit
Chart interval
Reported bars
Coverage ratio
Gold Snap
M1
7,901,463
0.9425
Logan
M15
559,285
1.0007
Gold Atlas
M30
280,941
1.0053
CryonX
H1
140,862
1.0081
The interval changes the count
All four audits cover XAUUSD from the same start date to the same end date. Their totals differ because one hourly bar represents much more time than one minute bar.
The bar count is therefore useful only beside the chart interval. Comparing the totals alone would make the finer chart look more complete even when the audits describe the same period.
Coverage is a ratio, not a grade
Each audit converts its bar total into minutes and compares that value with an expected weekday total. Coarser bars receive their full interval even when trading occupied only part of it.
That is why a coverage ratio can sit slightly above one. It does not mean the history contains extra time, and a lower ratio on a finer chart does not by itself prove missing market data.
Read three fields together
Use the reported bars, chart interval and coverage method as one block. A late first trade is more informative when the history reaches the requested start, but the ratio cannot tell you which individual minutes are absent.
Every audit page names the version it measured, the number of recorded version entries and the price on the day we checked it. On 4 September 2026 Ultimate Breakout System counted 52 entries and five further builds after the 7.0 we tested, Logan recorded 35 entries in nine weeks, and Smart Gold Impulse had one build (2.0) after the 1.00 we measured. Four products changed price inside our archive window, one of them three times.
Census of 6 September 2026: Every catalog run is measured on a 100,000 USD frame with a 0.01 base lot input and none of them is judged on it. The 22 audits that carry the block evaluate on vendor deposits from 100 to 2,000 USD, six of them on our 1,000 USD fallback because the vendor names none. Scalping Robot Pro survives the frame at 46,765.32 USD and kills a 1,000 USD account 53 times over the same trades.